Criminal Indictment in Israel: What to Do from the First Moment and How the Process Works


דרג את המאמר
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney

Receiving a criminal indictment is a shattering moment, a moment in which a person’s life changes at once. What may have begun as a suspicion, an interrogation, or an arrest, becomes a threatening legal reality. The indictment is the official document submitted to the court, which details the offenses you allegedly committed and the evidence the prosecution intends to present against you. It marks the transition from the crossroads of the investigation to the heart of the criminal trial process, and its implications are dramatic: a criminal record, the danger of imprisonment, heavy fines, and irreversible harm to your good name and to your personal and professional reputation.

Did you receive a criminal indictment? What to do from the first moment

An indictment is the beginning of a criminal proceeding that may end in conviction and punishment. At the first stage it is worth clarifying exactly what is attributed to you, what the evidence is, when the first hearing is, and whether there is room to request cancellation of the indictment or an arrangement.

  • Read the indictment and write down the offenses, the facts and the witnesses.
  • Do not give another version to the police or to the prosecution, and do not contact the witnesses.
  • Do not ignore the date set for the hearing, because failure to appear may lead to a bench warrant or arrest.
  • Consult an attorney before the first hearing.

I am Adv. and Notary Emanuel Trach, with 15 years of experience in criminal defense. I represent defendants from the investigation to the end of the proceeding.

Call: 055-2550011Send a WhatsApp message

As relevant: Cancelling a criminal indictment, Conditional arrangement, Pre-indictment hearing, Building offenses and Business licensing. After a conviction: Erasing a criminal record.

At this moment, when you stand before the well-oiled and threatening system, you need a guiding hand, professional and uncompromising representation. The office of Adv. Emanuel Trach is experienced in representing defendants in all types of offenses and in all instances, and understands the enormous significance of every stage of the proceeding. We are here to protect your rights, to fight for your innocence, and to strive for an acquittal or the best result for you.

 

What is a criminal indictment and why is it so significant?

An indictment is the core of the criminal proceeding. It is in effect the “claim” of the state against a citizen, alleging that he committed a criminal offense. The indictment details the facts attributed to the defendant, the sections of law he allegedly violated, and the list of prosecution witnesses and the evidence that will be presented against him.

The importance of the indictment is enormous for several reasons:

  • Beyond the presumption of innocence: Although under Israeli law a person is considered innocent until proven guilty, the moment an indictment is filed, the status of the suspect changes to defendant. He is forced to deal with an exhausting, expensive and often also public legal proceeding, in order to prove his innocence or to reduce the severity of the accusations.

  • Potential for punishment:
    The filing of an indictment opens the door to the imposition of severe penalties, from monetary fines, through community service, a suspended sentence, and up to actual imprisonment for many years, depending on the severity of the offense.

  • Implications for the criminal record:
    A conviction following an indictment leaves a criminal record in the police and criminal register. Such a record may severely harm your future: it may prevent acceptance to certain jobs (especially in the public sector, in the defense establishment, or in positions requiring a security clearance), harm the ability to obtain licenses (for example, law, medicine), and cause difficulties in immigration or obtaining visas to foreign countries.

  • Harm to reputation and good name:
    Even if in the end the case is closed with an acquittal, the very filing of the indictment and the public exposure may severely harm reputation and social, family and professional standing.


The process of filing an indictment – what happens behind the scenes?

The filing of an indictment is the culmination of a lengthy investigative process. The process includes several main stages:

  1. Police investigation: The first stage, in which the police collect evidence, take testimonies, carry out searches, detentions and arrests, and try to establish the suspicions against the suspect.
  2. Transfer of the investigation file to a prosecution unit: At the end of the investigation, the police transfer the file (if they believe that sufficient evidence has been collected) with their recommendations to a prosecution unit – usually the State Attorney’s Office (in serious cases) or the police prosecution (in lighter cases).
  3. Examination of the evidence by the prosecution: The prosecution examines the evidentiary material collected by the police. It is not bound by the police’s recommendations, and the final discretion whether to file an indictment, and which charges to include in it, is in its hands.
  4. The hearing stage (before the filing of an indictment): This is a critical and especially important stage. Section 60A of the Criminal Procedure Law provides that before an indictment is filed for a felony (an offense whose penalty is more than 3 years’ imprisonment), the prosecution authorities must send the suspect a notice of their intention to file an indictment against him, and enable him to present his arguments (in writing or orally) within 30 days. The purpose of the hearing is to try to persuade the prosecution to retract its intention, to cancel the indictment, to reduce the severity of the charges, or to reach a lenient plea arrangement. This is a last window of opportunity before things become official and public, and therefore the importance of legal representation at this stage is enormous (see also a separate page on the criminal pre-indictment hearing).
  5. Filing of the indictment: If after the hearing (or if no hearing was held) the prosecution still believes there is a basis for filing an indictment, it is formally filed with the court.


The legal proceeding after the filing of an indictment – step by step

After the indictment is filed, the criminal proceeding begins in court, which is usually complex and long:

  1. Reading of the indictment and the response: This is the first hearing in court. The defendant is called to give his answer to the indictment – whether he admits, denies (disputes) or remains silent. In most cases, the charges are denied, and then the stage of conducting the evidentiary hearings begins.
  2. The evidentiary stage (bringing witnesses and presenting evidence): This is usually the central and longest stage of the trial.
    • Prosecution witnesses: The prosecution summons its witnesses (police officers, investigators, complainants, eyewitnesses, experts) and presents its evidence (documents, reports, photographs, recordings). The defendant’s attorney conducts a cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses in order to challenge their credibility, to contradict their version or to point to flaws in the evidence.
    • Defense witnesses: After the prosecution’s case concludes, the defense may present its witnesses and evidence (the defendant himself, alibi witnesses, defense experts).
  3. Summations: After all the evidence and testimonies have been presented, each of the parties (the prosecution and the defense) submits summations in writing and/or orally, in which it analyzes the evidence and presents its legal arguments and conclusions.
  4. Verdict: The judge examines all the evidentiary material and arguments and decides whether the prosecution has proven the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
    • Acquittal: If the judge was not persuaded of the defendant’s guilt.
    • Conviction: If the judge was persuaded of the defendant’s guilt.
  5. Sentencing arguments: If the defendant was convicted, the sentencing arguments stage follows. At this stage, the prosecution presents arguments for a harsher sentence, and the defense presents arguments for a lenient sentence, referring to the entirety of the defendant’s personal and family circumstances, his criminal past (or its absence), his contribution to society, rehabilitation processes he has undergone and more. Sometimes a probation service report is submitted.
  6. Sentence: The judge determines the final sentence, which may include: a fine, an undertaking, community service, a suspended sentence, actual imprisonment, compensation to the victim and more. In certain cases, there may also be non-conviction (although guilt was proven), when the court believes that a conviction would severely and disproportionately harm the defendant, and it is possible to settle for other punitive measures.
  7. Appeal: Each party has the right to appeal the verdict and/or the sentence to a higher instance (from the Magistrates’ Court to the District Court, and from the District Court to the Supreme Court).


How does Adv. Emanuel Trach defend you against an indictment?

Professional legal representation is the key to success in dealing with an indictment. The office of Adv. Emanuel Trach offers comprehensive and uncompromising accompaniment throughout the proceeding:

  1. In-depth and meticulous examination of the evidentiary material (the “investigation material”):

    • Immediately upon receiving the indictment and the investigation material (which includes all the testimonies, documents, recordings, photographs and any other evidence collected), Adv. Trach dives into it.
    • He analyzes every document, every testimony, every detail, and looks for:
      • Evidentiary flaws: Are there holes in the prosecution’s evidence? Is a certain piece of evidence inadmissible legally?
      • Contradictions in testimonies: Are there contradictions between different testimonies, or within the testimony of a single witness? Such contradictions may undermine the credibility of the witnesses.
      • Legal or procedural defects: Were the suspect’s rights violated in the interrogation? Were searches or property seizures carried out unlawfully? These defects may lead to disqualification of evidence or even cancellation of the indictment.
      • Weak points: Identifying weaknesses in the prosecution’s case that can be exploited for the benefit of the defense.
  2. Formulating a personally tailored defense strategy:

    • After analyzing the evidentiary material and in-depth consultation with you, Adv. Trach will build a unique defense strategy for your case.
    • The strategy may include:
      • Striving for a complete acquittal: If the evidence is weak, Adv. Trach will fight for a full acquittal in court, while conducting a full evidentiary trial.
      • Cancelling the indictment: In certain cases, it is possible to approach the State Attorney’s Office with a reasoned request to cancel the indictment even before the trial begins, following substantial flaws that were found.
      • Conducting negotiations for a lenient plea arrangement: In cases where the evidence is strong, and where it is in the defendant’s interest to avoid the risk of a long and expensive trial, Adv. Trach will conduct intensive negotiations with the prosecution to reach a plea arrangement. Such an arrangement may lead to significant relief in the counts of the indictment (for example, a reduction from a felony to a misdemeanor), or to a significantly lenient sentence (for example, a suspended sentence instead of actual imprisonment, or cancellation of a conviction).
      • Conditional arrangement: In certain cases and depending on the type of offense, it is possible to strive to close the case by means of a conditional arrangement, which completely prevents the filing of an indictment and a conviction (see a separate page).
  3. Professional and determined representation in court:

    • Conducting cross-examinations: Adv. Trach will cross-examine the prosecution witnesses in a professional and determined manner, in order to challenge their credibility, to expose contradictions in their version or to reduce the weight of their testimony.
    • Presenting defense evidence: He will summon defense witnesses (if there are any), submit documents and evidence supporting your version, and make sure that all your righteousness is presented before the court.
    • Brilliant legal arguments: At the end of the evidentiary stage, Adv. Trach will present reasoned and powerful legal summations, which will persuade the judge of the defendant’s innocence or present before him the mitigating circumstances.
    • Sentencing arguments: If, heaven forbid, you were convicted, Adv. Trach will present before the court the entirety of the mitigating personal circumstances (absence of a criminal past, family situation, medical problems, rehabilitation processes) in order to bring about the lightest possible sentence, including striving for non-conviction in appropriate cases.
  4. Filing appeals:

    • If the court convicted you or imposed on you a sentence that is unjust, Adv. Trach will not hesitate to file an appeal to a higher instance, in order to correct the legal injustice.


The importance of a quick response and professional advice – do not waste time!

The most important thing at the moment of receiving the indictment is to act immediately. Any delay or mistake at this stage may significantly harm the chances of success:

  • Missing deadlines: Various legal actions (such as filing a request for a hearing or preparing a statement of defense) have short and rigid deadlines. Failure to meet them may harm your rights.
  • Loss of evidence: As time passes, evidence that may assist your defense (such as security videos, eyewitnesses, documentation of events) may disappear or become impossible to obtain.
  • Missing negotiation opportunities: The earlier you act, the greater the chances of reaching a lenient plea arrangement or of closing the case at early stages, before the “wheels” of the full legal proceeding begin to move at full speed.

Therefore, from the moment you receive the indictment, the first and most important action is to contact an experienced criminal defense attorney immediately.


Adv. Emanuel Trach – your defender against an indictment

Dealing with a criminal indictment is one of the hardest challenges in a person’s life. Do not deal with it alone. The office of Adv. Emanuel Trach brings with it rich experience, deep legal knowledge, and the ability to conduct negotiations and representation in the courts at all instances. We will accompany you step by step, from the moment of receiving the indictment until the end of the legal proceedings, with professionalism, sensitivity and uncompromising determination.

Our supreme goal is to protect your freedom, your good name, and your future. Whether the goal is a complete acquittal, a plea arrangement that will prevent imprisonment or reduce the sentence, or preventing a criminal record – we will fight for you in every legal and lawful way.

Receiving an indictment requires an immediate and professional response.

Contact us today to schedule an urgent consultation meeting to examine your indictment and formulate a winning defense strategy.

Do not deal with it alone. We are here for you.

 

 

 

Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney
Indictment | What to do when an indictment is filed against you | Legal representation indictment | Indictment lawyer | Indictment defense attorney

Questions and answers about a criminal indictment

What happens after an indictment is filed?

A case is opened in court and a first hearing is set, in which the defendant responds to the indictment. If he denies it, an evidentiary stage is conducted. If there is a conviction, the court hears sentencing arguments and imposes the sentence.

What is a reading of the indictment?

The hearing at which the indictment is read and the defendant responds whether he admits or denies. It is worth consulting before the reading, because the answer affects the continuation of the proceeding.

Is it possible to cancel an indictment?

Sometimes. It is possible to argue, among other things, defects in the proceeding, the statute of limitations, defense of justice, or that the offense was repealed. There is no guarantee of a result, and every case is examined according to its circumstances.

Is it possible to avoid a conviction?

In appropriate circumstances yes, for example in a plea arrangement in which the court does not convict, under Section 192A of the Criminal Procedure Law. It depends on the offense, the circumstances, the prosecution’s position and the court’s decision.

Is an indictment a conviction?

No. The defendant is considered innocent until convicted. A criminal record is created following a conviction.

Is it possible to get a public defender, and why hire a private attorney?

In certain cases one is entitled to a public defender. One who chooses a private attorney chooses who accompanies him and when the familiarity with the case begins, and can consult already before the reading. The decision is personal.

How long does the proceeding take and how much does representation cost?

There is no uniform time and no uniform price. The time depends on the offense, the type of proceeding and the court’s workload, and the fee is agreed in a written agreement.

See also: Criminal lawyer – Representation in criminal proceedings, from investigation to trial.

Contact for

Legal advice without obligation

    055-2550011

    Contact us

    Submit the form and we will get back to you as soon as possible.

      Skip to content