Violating a Threatening Harassment Order in Israel: A Criminal Offense and Its Consequences
תוכן עניינים
Toggle
Did you receive an order against threatening harassment? Whether you think it is justified or outrageous, and whether you appeared at the hearing or the order was issued ex parte – from the moment the order takes effect, you must understand well the consequences of violating it. Violating a threatening harassment order is no small matter; it is a serious criminal offense, which may lead to arrest, the filing of an indictment, actual imprisonment, and a criminal record in your criminal register. Many are unaware of the gravity of the situation, and find themselves entangled in big trouble only because they did not understand the restrictions imposed on them or the consequences of disobeying the order.
At the office of Adv. Emanuel Trach we understand the complexity and sensitivity of dealing with threatening harassment orders, and in particular with their violations. We represent both parties who were harmed by a violation of an order and demand its enforcement, and parties accused of violating an order, and help them deal with the severe legal consequences.
If you or someone you know is accused of violating a threatening harassment order, do not hesitate for a moment – act immediately. An experienced attorney is the key to protecting your freedom and your future.
What is an order against threatening harassment? A reminder and the context of violating a threatening harassment order
Before we talk about the violation, let us briefly recall what a threatening harassment order is. It is anchored in the Prevention of Threatening Harassment Law, 5762-2001, and is intended to grant protection to a person harmed by repeated harassment that instills fear in him, or harms his privacy or freedom. Section 2(a) of the law defines “threatening harassment” as:
“Any of the following, when repeated, whether by act or by words, and the conduct of the harasser is likely to instill fear in a person, or to harm his privacy or freedom:
(1) Stalking, following, making contact or attempts to make contact with a person, directly or indirectly;
(2) Threats to harm the body or property of a person or of another person, or to humiliate, degrade or harm the good name of a person or of another person;
(3) Harm to a person’s privacy, including publication of personal details, false or misleading information, or photographing, documenting or distributing images or videos that violate a person’s privacy;
(4) Harassment in any other way intended to harm a person, his privacy or freedom, or to instill fear in him.”
The order itself, as mentioned in Section 4(a) of the law, may include a variety of provisions, such as a prohibition on making threats, a prohibition on making contact (direct or indirect), a prohibition on approaching a place of residence or work, a prohibition on stalking and following, a prohibition on harming privacy and more. It is issued for a period of up to six months, and may be extended up to a year (and in exceptional cases even longer).
Violating a threatening harassment order – a criminal offense: Section 10 of the law
The most critical provision in this context, and the reason for the gravity of the matter, is found in Section 10 of the Prevention of Threatening Harassment Law, which states explicitly:
“One who violates a provision of an order against threatening harassment, shall be liable to imprisonment for one year.”
The meaning of the section is clear and unequivocal: a violation of any of the provisions included in the order, even if it seems to you marginal or unintentional, constitutes a criminal offense. This is not merely a civil issue, in which the violator pays a fine or bears damages; it is an offense for which the legislature prescribed a prison sentence, and therefore it is handled by the police and the prosecution like any other criminal offense.
What is considered a “violation” of the order?
Any act expressly contrary to the provisions of the order is considered a violation. It is important to understand that even acts that seem innocent or “harmless” may be considered a violation:
- Direct or indirect contact: Sending a single text message, responding to a social media post, a phone call, or even asking a mutual friend to pass on a message – all of these may be considered a violation of the no-contact prohibition.
- Physical approach: Being in a place defined in the order as forbidden to enter (for example, proximity to a place of residence or work), even if by “chance,” may be considered a violation.
- Surveillance or stalking: Driving along a certain route that appears to be stalking, or repeated presence in areas where the victim is located, even if there was no actual intent to harass.
- Publication of information: Any publication on social networks, or on any other platform, that harms the privacy protected in the order.
- Harassment through third parties: An attempt to contact or harass the victim through relatives, friends or mutual acquaintances.
- Taunting or provocation: Even if the other party is the one who initiated contact or tried to provoke you, a response on your part may be considered a violation.
It is important to remember that the court does not always focus on the “intent of the violator,” but on the “harmful result” and on the question of whether the act was carried out contrary to an explicit provision in the order.
The practical consequences of violating a threatening harassment order
Violating a threatening harassment order entails a series of severe consequences, both on the criminal level and on the personal level:
- Immediate arrest and police interrogation:
- From the moment the victim reports to the police a violation of the order (and presents evidence of it), the police will usually act immediately to arrest the violator of the order.
- The arrest may take place at home, in the street or at any other place, and will usually be carried out suddenly.
- After the arrest, the violator will be interrogated under caution at the police station on suspicion of committing the criminal offense of violating an order.
- An initial arrest may last up to 24 hours, after which the police may ask the court for an extension of remand for the purposes of the investigation.
- Filing of a criminal indictment:
- If the police believe there is sufficient evidence to prove the violation of the order, the investigation file will be transferred to the prosecution (police prosecution or the State Attorney’s Office).
- The prosecution, if it finds a public interest and sufficient evidence, will file a criminal indictment for the offense of violating a threatening harassment order.
- This proceeding is in addition to (and does not cancel) the original order proceeding. That is, even if an indictment was filed against you, the original order remains in force and you must continue to obey it.
- Severe punishment:
- If you are convicted of the offense of violating a threatening harassment order, the court may impose on you a prison sentence of up to one year.
- The courts treat the violation of judicial orders with particular severity, and tend to impose actual prison sentences, particularly in cases of repeated violations or cases in which the violation included violence or additional threats.
- Beyond imprisonment, additional penalties may be imposed such as fines, a suspended sentence, or compensation to the victim.
- Criminal record:
- A conviction for the offense of violating a threatening harassment order leaves a criminal record in your police and criminal register.
- Such a criminal record may dramatically harm your future:
- Employment: Preventing acceptance to certain jobs (such as public service, security, education), or obtaining professional licenses (for example, law, medicine).
- Immigration options: Difficulties obtaining visas or citizenship in foreign countries.
- Personal and social reputation: Social stigma and severe harm to your good name.
- Aggravation of the conditions of the original order or its extension:
- Violating a threatening harassment order may lead to a request by the injured party or the prosecution to aggravate the conditions of the original order, or to extend its validity for a more significant period of time, since a violation of the order indicates dangerousness.
How does Adv. Emanuel Trach defend defendants in violating a threatening harassment order?
If you have been accused of violating a threatening harassment order, you need urgent and professional legal representation. At the office of Adv. Emanuel Trach, we go into immediate action and provide comprehensive legal accompaniment, while determinedly dealing with all stages of the proceeding:
- Immediate response in arrest:
- If you were arrested, we are available 24/7. We will arrive at the police station as soon as possible, meet you, explain your rights to you (especially the right to silence and the right to consult an attorney before interrogation), and advise you on how to conduct yourself in the interrogation.
- We will act for your release from arrest as soon as possible, whether by persuading the police or by approaching the court for an urgent arrest-extension hearing.
- Gathering counter-evidence and analyzing the prosecution’s case:
- We will request the investigation material from the police and examine it meticulously.
- We will look for flaws in the prosecution’s evidence, contradictions in testimonies, or procedural failures committed by the police.
- We will gather evidence that will contradict the prosecution’s claims about the violation of the order, for example:
- Alibi proofs.
- Security camera footage.
- Testimonies of eyewitnesses who will prove that no violation was committed.
- Recordings or messages that will prove that the other party was the one who initiated the contact, or that the documentation does not prove a violation.
- Proof that the order was not served on you properly.
- Formulating a personally tailored defense strategy:
- Based on the evidence gathered and the analysis of the case, we will formulate an effective defense strategy for you. The strategy may include:
- Striving for acquittal: If the evidence is weak or capable of being refuted.
- Denying the act: If you claim that you did not commit what is attributed to you.
- Filing a request to cancel the original order: If the original order was issued unjustifiably, it is possible, in parallel, to try to cancel it.
- Negotiating a plea arrangement: In cases where the evidence is strong, we will act to conduct negotiations with the prosecution to reach a lenient plea arrangement, which may include cancellation of the indictment, reduction of the counts of the indictment, avoiding a criminal record (such as non-conviction), or a lenient sentence.
- Based on the evidence gathered and the analysis of the case, we will formulate an effective defense strategy for you. The strategy may include:
- Determined representation in court:
- We will represent https://www.nevo.co.il/law_html/law00/229549.htm you at all court hearings, both the arrest hearings and the conducting of the criminal case itself.
- We will conduct effective cross-examinations of the prosecution witnesses.
- We will present the defense evidence in a professional and convincing manner.
- We will present brilliant legal arguments that will refute the prosecution’s claims.
- At the sentencing arguments stage (if, heaven forbid, you were convicted), we will present the entirety of the mitigating circumstances in order to bring about the lightest possible sentence, including a request for non-conviction.
- Handling additional consequences:
- We will also accompany you in all the related consequences, such as submitting a request to cancel the criminal record (where possible) or handling the implications for the original order.
Preventing future violations and removing risks
As part of the advice, Adv. Emanuel Trach will explain to you in a detailed and clear manner all the restrictions of the order that was issued against you. It is important to understand well the provisions of the order and to avoid any action, even the smallest, that may be interpreted as a violation. In many cases, a click on a “like” or viewing the other party’s story is enough to be considered a violator of an order, if the order prohibits any indirect contact or surveillance.
Complete avoidance of any contact, direct or indirect, of any approach, and of any action that may be interpreted as a violation, is the key to preventing further criminal complications. One must act with extra caution and refrain entirely from any attempt to communicate, even if it seems to you that the other party initiated contact, or that there is no bad intent behind your act.
Do not deal with it alone – act immediately!
If you were accused of violating a threatening harassment order, you face real legal danger. The accompaniment of an experienced criminal defense attorney, specializing in this field, is essential. He will know how to gather the required evidence, how to present your version convincingly, and how to fight for your freedom in court.
At the office of Adv. Emanuel Trach we understand the urgency and sensitivity of your situation. We provide a fast, professional and personal response, and act with determination to protect your rights, prevent a criminal conviction, and minimize the most harmful consequences.
Do not hesitate and do not wait until the last moment! If you were accused of violating a threatening harassment order – contact us immediately for urgent legal advice and firm legal defense.
Contact Adv. Emanuel Trach
Phone: 055-2550011
Address: 94 Yigal Alon Street, Tel Aviv – Jaffa, Alon 2 Towers, 4th floor.
Email: Emanuel@Trach-law.co.il
Your freedom and your good name are at the top of our priorities.
Keywords:
- Violation of a threatening harassment order
- Criminal offense violation of an order
- Criminal record violation of an order
- Arrest violation of a harassment order
- Indictment violation of an order
- Prevention of Threatening Harassment Law Section 10
- Representation in violation of a harassment order
- Legal defense violation of an order
- Criminal lawyer violation of an order
- Order against threatening harassment
- Release from arrest violation of an order
- Legal advice violation of an order
- Consequences of violating a restraining order (a common synonym)
- Punishment for violating a harassment order
- Preventing a criminal record violation of an order
See also: Criminal lawyer – Representation in criminal proceedings, from investigation to trial.
See also: An order against threatening harassment: guide and representation.
Contact for
Legal advice without obligation